Veteran AFL journalist Caroline Wilson has declared St Kilda is “a horrible soccer membership” with “abysmal” recruiting following the shock sacking of Brett Ratten.

It comes as delisted Saints defender Jarrod Lienert declared his shock on the transfer, which got here only a few months after Ratten signed a multi-year contract extension.

“He’s probably the most caring bloke I’ve ever met, he’s such a real bloke,” Lienert informed SEN SA.

Watch each match of the AFLW Season LIVE on Kayo. New to Kayo? Start your free trial now >

“I used to be stunned when he was sacked however the again half of the 12 months we gave him didn’t assist.”

Ratten’s departure was simply one other mistake by the Saints lately, based on Wilson, who pointed to CEO Simon Lethlean because the supply of various them.

Lethlean was one in all two senior AFL executives who had been compelled to give up the league over inappropriate relationships with youthful AFL staffers, however months later he was appointed GM of soccer at St Kilda, then changing into their CEO in 2022.

He and St Kilda president Andrew Bassat conceded they “blindsided” Ratten with the decision to sack him after the trade period.

“What most likely made Ratten worse is that he was re-signed solely 100 days or so in the past on a two-year deal,” Wilson stated on her Don’t Shoot the Messenger podcast.

“If you’re a membership that receives cash from the AFL and owes some huge cash and has the worst debt within the AFL, they aren’t allowed to signal long-term contracts, there would have been a six-month payout.

“However nonetheless, that six months for a membership that has bought not a lot cash, the footy boss (Lethlean) on the time is now the CEO, I don’t know whether or not he’s saying it was the outdated CEO’s choice to re-sign the coach, I hope not as a result of he was the pinnacle of footy and would have had a giant say in it.

“One of many issues is you’ve bought a man who has are available in as head of footy in Simon Lethlean who has had points on the AFL as we all know and needed to go away the AFL when he was on a trajectory there, he’s are available in as footy boss and he has made some unhealthy calls as head of footy. The primary one was getting Dan Hannebery from the Swans. The recruiting has been fairly abysmal.

“They’ve introduced in Geoff Walsh over the 2 males Lethlean needed to run issues. They’ve mainly knocked again his first envisaged construction of the footy division.

“Now they’ve determined they need Ross Lyon to teach. This overview has been happening since early September and I collect the president was telling folks about it on Lindsay Fox’s yacht and also you’ve bought all these former membership presidents there.

“They’re a horrible soccer membership. They’ve been run so badly for therefore lengthy.

“I simply assume – to make Ratten go in and plead for his job after being informed he’s come out badly within the overview after which just about making him wait exterior the door whereas the board meets for a couple of extra hours earlier than they emerge and inform him he’s gone – anyway. It’s not fairly. That was unhealthy.”

The Saints are actually strongly inquisitive about reappointing Ross Lyon as senior coach having held a number of conferences with the person who took them to a few Grand Finals over a decade in the past.