The Killing of Ayman al-Zawahiri

It’s potential that the terrorist chief, needed for his function in plotting the 9/11 assaults and later changing into the pinnacle of al Qaeda after the killing of Osama bin Laden in 2011, didn’t know demise was coming.

A few of the particulars of the operation that killed him had been shared by President Biden throughout a televised handle on Monday night. Different particulars have been shared by senior administration officers who spoke to reporters on the situation of anonymity.

Senior intelligence officers instructed the Associated Press that al-Zawahiri had relocated to Afghanistan and sought refuge together with his household in a home in downtown Kabul, a home owned by a prime aide to senior Taliban chief Sirajuddin Haqqani.

Those that had been monitoring him waited patiently for years, and over the previous a number of months, had been capable of construct a sample of life through impartial sources that helped knowledgeable the president’s resolution to hold out the strike.

Like his predecessor Osama bin Laden, officials say the al Qaeda chief was recognized on a balcony on a number of events and by April, there was sufficient confidence within the probability that they’d discovered him, that the president was briefed.

Finally, demise was delivered with a Hellfire Missile launched from a  drone in what some officers have mentioned was an operation managed by the CIA.  A CIA floor staff reportedly confirmed that the sufferer of the strike was certainly al-Zawahiri.  White Home Nationwide Safety Advisor Jake Sullivan instructed ABC’s “Good Morning America” that “there was no person on the bottom in uniform when the strike occurred.”

The Cipher Temporary reached out to a spread of specialists to get their ideas on what the killing of al-Zawahiri means right now.

Normal David Petraeus (Ret.), US Military (Ret.), former Commander of the Surge in Iraq, US Central Command, NATO/US Forces in Afghanistan and former Director of the CIA

The operation that introduced Ayman Al-Zawahiri to justice in Kabul may be very important in plenty of respects.  First, it clearly eliminates the Emir of Al Qaeda who changed Osama Bin Laden and essentially the most outstanding AQ chief aside from Osama bin Laden; in actual fact, Zawahiri had been at bin Laden’s aspect since Zawahiri merged Egyptian Islamic Jihad with AQ within the late Nineties and sometimes has been seen because the “brains” behind lots of the most sensational assaults carried out by AQ.  This strike thus brings to an finish the bloody extremist profession of somebody accountable for innumerable assaults over a number of many years on members of the US navy, Americans, our allies all over the world, and our very lifestyle – assaults that embrace the East Africa Embassy bombings, the assault on the USS Cole, the 9/11 assaults, and plenty of extra.  Second, this operation is a big success for our intelligence and counter-terrorism communities and it reminds us of the continued significance of what they do, even within the wake of the destruction a number of years in the past of the Islamic State Caliphate in northern Iraq and northeastern Syria and the harm carried out to lots of the remaining parts of the Islamic State and Al Qaeda there and all over the world.  Third, it additionally demonstrates the power of our intelligence and CT communities to function in opposition to extremists in Afghanistan from “over the horizon,” even with out bases in Afghanistan any longer – and that’s notably essential given the expansion and actions of the Islamic State’s Khorasan Group in Afghanistan because the Taliban regime took management of the nation and given the challenges IS-KG is posing to the Taliban.  And fourth, it exhibits that the Taliban are flagrantly violating their commitments within the Doha Settlement and publicly to not enable worldwide extremists to have sanctuary in Afghanistan.  On condition that Zawahiri was reportedly being sheltered by Sirajuddin Haqqani, one of many Taliban regime’s most senior leaders (and a chosen terrorist with a large reward on his head), it’s clear that Al Qaeda remains to be very shut with the Taliban.  And this ought to be a warning to the US and the world of the necessity to maintain important strain on the extremists in Afghanistan – noting that the Islamic State is essentially the most worrisome of them at current. In sum, this can be a superb day for the US and our allies and companions all over the world – in addition to for the members of the communities who labored collectively so skillfully to convey to justice such a major, harmful, and elusive extremist chief. But it surely additionally carries a warning that we must proceed to focus appreciable property on Afghanistan and the extremists profiting from the scenario there.

As a “plank proprietor” of the Bin Ladin Job Drive (Alec Station) began in January of 1996, I’m extraordinarily happy with my Company colleagues’ perseverance in, like with Bin Ladin, by no means forgetting the likes of Al-Zawahiri.  Though some could argue that it’ll not slowdown future terrorist acts, I disagree.  No totally different than a death-sentence for homicide, it deters.  Or, on the very least, it cripples their means to plan future assaults in opposition to the US and our allies, with impunity.  It makes their actions go deeper underground and those that know our craft, know this. Now, I simply want we may go after the handfuls of recognized terrorists who’re residing overtly in so many locations outdoors of warfare zones, and who even have the blood of our Countrymen on their arms. Though a part of CIA’s Counterterrorist Middle’s (CTC) motto is Preempt, Disrupt… the most effective one which involves thoughts is our pin from the Nineties that claims, “Anytime, Anyplace, Nevertheless Lengthy it Takes.” In reminiscence of Mike Spann, Jennifer Mathews, Gary Schroen, and plenty of others.

The Hon. Susan Gordon, former Principal Deputy Director of Nationwide Intelligence

I’ve so many ideas following the information of the killing of Al-Zawahri, amongst them: that the true work of nationwide safety is a each day grind executed by tireless professionals out of the medial highlight, they’re centered on maintaining America and her pursuits and allies secure via arduous work, ingenuity, and perseverance; that Intelligence Neighborhood continues to ship benefit, even in a altering world; and that the put up 9/11 mantra of “We’ll always remember” was by no means only a tag line for the men and women who serve their flip. It isn’t the tip to the terrorist risk, but it surely’s indicator that the counter forces are nicely engaged.

Gen. Joseph Votel (Ret.), former CENTCOM Commander

Congratulations to our CT professionals who orchestrated this essential strike.  It demonstrates that the US won’t ever falter in bringing those that assault or plot in opposition to our residents or pursuits to justice.  It additionally reminds us that efficient counter-terrorism operations require persistence, perseverance, and sustained sources.  It is a long-game and whereas we should essentially concentrate on sustaining our aggressive edge in opposition to China, we will by no means take our focus off the persistent risk of terrorism.

Lt. Gen. Scott Howell (Ret.), former Commander, Joint Particular Operations Command

I’m extremely impressed with the operation to search out, repair, and end al-Qa’ida emir Ayman al-Zawahiri after over twenty years of being in hiding.  The operation is much more spectacular given the constraints of the post-withdrawal working surroundings in Afghanistan. Executing any such strike within the absence of U.S. boots on the bottom, with a sharply lowered intelligence infrastructure, restricted basing entry within the area, and with out civilian casualties speaks volumes to the potential, ability, and professionalism of U.S. concentrating on and counterterrorism efforts. My compliments to the intelligence and counter-terrorism professionals who remained laser-focused over a few years.  The painstaking work of sifting via bits of intelligence, discovering connections, questioning assumptions, crafting assessments, and dealing via a number of layers of contingencies & “what-ifs” requires a excessive diploma of dedication and stamina. This was a daring mission that risked hostile ramifications for U.S. pursuits if it had been perceived as a clumsy reengagement or as inflicting extra struggling for the Afghan folks. As an alternative, the surgical strike in densely populated Kabul precipitated no civilian casualties or collateral harm and eliminated a generational grasp of terror.  It sends a powerful message that U.S. counterterrorism strain is persistent, exact and unrelenting.

James Clapper, former Director of Nationwide Intelligence, ODNI

This was, by any measure, a unprecedented intelligence accomplishment. And it represents one other type of closure for 9/11 victims and households. It now has I believe, extra symbolic significance since Zawahiri had so remoted himself bodily and electronically, that he had turn into an ideological figurehead greater than an operational chief.  I’ve to consider he should’ve let down his operational safety guard by shifting to Kabul, and that apparently opened the intelligence aperture.

John McLaughlin, former Performing CIA Director

President Biden is true to emphasise the significance of delivering justice to Ayman al-Zawahiri. Subsequent data makes clear that this was the results of months of affected person intelligence work and the power to behave on that with extraordinary precision. Zawahiri had nice credibility within the Jihadi motion going again to his opposition to the Egyptian authorities years in the past. He contributed a strategic perspective to enrich bin Laden‘s charisma (which Zawahiri lacked). Lately, I might characterize him as retaining respect inside the motion however not quite a lot of authority. A lot of the authority, and precise functionality, had flowed to Al-Qaeda associates in locations like Yemen, Syria, and components of north and sub-Saharan Africa. All of them working, I consider with minimal course from central authority, which had misplaced amongst different issues the power to assist them financially. So, his demise doesn’t dramatically impression the management of Al-Qaeda, which is now so broadly distributed. The place Zawahiri might need mattered most was in brokering a permissive surroundings for an Al-Qaeda revival in Afghanistan, which can have accounted for his presence there. The truth that he was killed within the coronary heart of Kabul exhibits that the Taliban is as soon as once more welcoming jihadist teams, or at the least Al-Qaeda, in contradiction of their counterterrorism pledges. They in all probability view Al-Qaeda as an ally in opposition to ISIS, which is far stronger, bigger, richer, and against the Taliban authorities. The success of the operation is testomony to the unrelenting focus at CIA on terrorism over 20 years; It by no means turned and on again-off once more factor. To borrow a line from an previous James Bond film theme music, “no person does it higher”. That is very arduous, detail-oriented work that depends on expertise, exact intelligence, refined judgment, persistence, and beautiful timing — and unremitting dedication. Not cheerleading for my previous colleagues, merely stating a truth.

Robert Cardillo, former Director, Nationwide Geospatial-Intelligence Company

The current US deliverance of justice to Ayman Al-Zawahri is a testomony to our enduring dedication to the reminiscences of all of these souls misplaced on 11 September 2001. All Individuals ought to be happy with our continued vigilance in protection of our freedom.


Subscriber+Members have the next degree of entry to Cipher Temporary Skilled Views on World Points. Upgrading to Subscriber+ Status now.

Learn extra expert-driven nationwide safety insights, perspective and evaluation in The Cipher Brief

Related Articles


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Latest Articles