How Israeli and U.S. Intelligence have rebounded since Hamas Assault

OPINION / EXPERT PERSPECTIVE — Israeli intelligence has regained its sea legs.  After the terrorist assault launched by Hamas final month, it’s clear that Shin Wager, Mossad, and Israeli navy intelligence are serving to the Israel Protection Forces (IDF) prosecute the conflict in sensible and expeditious trend. 

Simply check out Israeli intelligence exercise over the previous few weeks.

– Mossad Director David Barnea is touring the area, specializing in hostage negotiations.  He’s on level now, the important thing participant for the Israeli authorities, because the hostage problem is of extraordinary significance to Israel. Shin Wager chief Ronen Bar additionally was in Egypt this previous week.

–  A Shin Wager hit team was created to trace down Hamas members chargeable for 10/7, in accordance with quite a lot of press reviews.  They, together with Mossad, will take the lengthy view just like how Mossad killed Palestinian terrorists chargeable for the 1972 Munich bloodbath.  The operation may take years.  Everybody related to Hamas is now a goal, together with the political management in locations like Qatar.

 – Israeli intelligence assist to the IDF has stepped up in Gaza, which incorporates (per the IDF’s Twitter/X feed) the systematic killing of Hamas Excessive Worth Targets.  Israel says it has eradicated half of the fight battalions, with reportedly a number of thousand Hamas operatives killed.  Of observe, the variety of rocket launches from Gaza are down dramatically as nicely.  The IDF has additionally captured Hamas strongholds in northern Gaza.  Of nice significance, IDF casualties, whereas tragic for the Israeli public, are decrease than anticipated.  In sum, the IDF, supported by Israeli intelligence, is doing much better than anticipated.

– Former Israeli intelligence officers I’ve spoken to notice an enormous sense of resolve throughout the Israeli nationwide safety group.  The Gaza marketing campaign to destroy Hamas is an existential combat for them.  This sense transcends the Israeli political spectrum.  Two issues might be true directly.  That Israelis, together with a lot of the nationwide safety group, detests Prime Minister Netanyahu.  Whereas on the identical time, are united within the absolute requirement to destroy Hamas. 

It’s not only for the President anymore. Cipher Transient Subscriber+Members have entry to their very own Open Source Daily Brief, conserving you updated on international occasions impacting nationwide safety.  It pays to be a Subscriber+Member.

U.S. intelligence is now again within the sport.  Just like the Israeli restoration after 10/7, U.S. intelligence has been mobilized.  The U.S. Intelligence Neighborhood (IC) had primarily ceded the Hamas target to Israel, as a result of we thought Shin Wager had Hamas coated. However Israel failed, and thus we have been left blind.  But the U.S. too, has pulled itself up by its bootstraps and are reportedly again in assortment mode. 

Simply check out present U.S. Intelligence posture.

– The U.S. has reportedly collected signals intelligence, in accordance with the Wall Road Journal that indicated that Hamas was utilizing the Al-Shifa hospital as a Command and Management (C2) node.  This means that the U.S. IC certainly has redirected sources to the battle. 

– The U.S. declassified those findings which in my opinion, was clearly designed to provide the Israelis some respiratory room.  The viewers for the U.S. motion is each international (ie countering the worldwide outrage over the Israeli siege of the hospital) and home, because the Biden administration was getting hammered internally throughout the Democratic Occasion ecosystem.

US IC Help to the IDF reportedly contains an Mq-9 drone that’s flying missions over Gaza for hostage restoration functions.

And there was expanded intelligence sharing with Israel, in accordance with press reports.

Cipher Transient Subscriber+Members take pleasure in limitless entry to Cipher Transient content material, together with evaluation with consultants, personal digital briefings with consultants, the M-F Open Supply Report and the weekly Useless Drop – an insider have a look at the most recent gossip within the nationwide safety house.  It pays to be a Subscriber+Member.

CIA Director Burns has additionally been traveling the region, for quite a lot of causes which have included a deal with hostage negotiations, in accordance with press reviews.

What comes subsequent for each intelligence companies?  The near-term focus of each intelligence communities in Israel and the U.S. will stay on figuring out the placement and restoration of the hostages.  However in my opinion, that’s extra tactical in nature.  It’s not strategic – as Israel will deal with a pause for hostage restoration as simply that, a pause, and never a stop hearth.  Actually, the most important strategic concern within the intelligence world is the prospect of regional escalation.

As such, all eyes within the intelligence world are on Israel’s northern border with Lebanon. 

Tensions have skyrocketed between the IDF and Hizballah.  And press reviews point out that there’s some concern within the U.S. administration that Israel could need a combat with Hizballah.  This has reportedly been the place of Israeli Minister Benny Gantz.  But Secretary of Protection Austin in a name a number of days in the past warned Gantz in opposition to this, in accordance with some press reviews.  

Of concern, there may be an escalation ladder that Israel and Hizballah comply with, and each are climbing it.  There isn’t a doubt that the Pentagon is worried.  The 2 service battle teams, 16 plane squadrons, and a U.S. nuclear submarine with 150 plus Tomahawk cruise missiles deployed in theater, are all deployed to discourage Hizballah (and actually Iran) from opening up one other entrance within the north.  If the ball does drop, it’s seemingly that the U.S. will become involved in placing Hizballah targets.  As such, for the U.S. and Israeli intelligence communities, the important thing assortment problem is to uncover the plans and intentions of Hizballah, which can really change daily.  It’s a dynamic state of affairs that wants fixed monitoring. 

For the U.S., simply as essential is our simmering battle with Iran, through their proxies in Syria and Iraq.  Our deterrence efforts to this point, are simply not working.  The U.S. navy struck two websites a number of days in the past, which was the proper factor to do.  However we simply can’t appear to comprise this.  Iran just isn’t listening.  The Pentagon, in accordance with media reviews, is annoyed.  So, the US intelligence group shall be laser targeted on gathering on Iranian choice making, and what they may do vis a vis their proxies. We could have to escalate to de-escalate earlier than U.S. forces are killed.

The credibility of each Israeli and U.S. intelligence is on the road, relating to what finally is discovered at al-Shifa hospital.  The IDF video displaying weapons recovered at al-Shifa is actually important, as this does exhibit the Hamas utilization of the hospital, which is technically a conflict crime.  As was the video of the hostages being moved all through the hospital on 10/7. That mentioned, given the U.S. and Israeli claims that the hospital contained a significant C2 node for Hamas, it’s most likely going to take further evidence-such as video of the particular tunnels underneath the hospital-to buttress the intelligence claims and assuage a number of the worldwide issues in regards to the Israeli strikes on the hospital.  Finally, corroborating the intelligence provides Israel extra runway diplomatically to prosecute the conflict in Gaza. 

The Cipher Transient is dedicated to publishing a variety of views on nationwide safety points submitted by deeply skilled nationwide safety professionals. 

Opinions expressed are these of the creator and don’t characterize the views or opinions of The Cipher Transient.

Have a perspective to share based mostly in your expertise within the nationwide safety area?  Ship it to [email protected] for publication consideration.

Learn extra expert-driven nationwide safety insights, perspective and evaluation in The Cipher Brief

Related Articles


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Latest Articles